Two couples for four nights. Here are the pros and cons:
Pros:
Great Location
Easy Parking
Price
Cons:
There were only four towels in the unit. With hiking, fishing, etc. this was not enough for 4 people over five days.
The towels and sheets all smelled like they had been left in the washer for a couple of days. I can tolerate a little funk but these were next level. Everything had to be rewashed (but no washer/dryer in unit)
No extra pillows or bedding. The beds each had two small pillows.
Less than one roll of toilet paper in the unit. We had to go buy our own.
No paper towels. Again, had to go buy which isn't a big deal but should be unnecessary.
Minimal kitchen amenities.
"sitting" chairs in the living room are horribly uncomfortable and built for a DMV waiting room, not an apartment where people want to sit and relax.
Hallway and stairs need to be either cleaned or re-carpeted (this unit is up three flights). There are some interesting odors as you ascend to the unit.
EXTREMELY noisy neighbors. I suspect a neighboring unit has been rented by seasonal workers who threw parties every night that lasted until 3 am. I had a tough time sleeping even after lots of whiskey. Fortunately, on Saturday night the police showed up (not from us calling) and broke things up around 1 am.
Lastly, and I agree this is trivial, the temp control in the shower is backwards. I initially thought there was no hot water but there is...once you turn the knob to cold.
As you can see, other than the neighbors, these issues are all easily resolved and hopefully the owners take these comments into consideration and make some changes that will allow the next tenants to leave a 5 star review.