I would give it 5 stars, but for the price, I would have expected it to be maintained a little better.
First, let me list all the reasons why you should rent this place:
LOCATION! The cottage is located at the south end of the Harbor and a little more protected by the wind than most of the harbor when it's windy (and it was windy for several nights & days during our stay)
THE DOCK! The dock is a "window into the sea" where we witnessed quite a few fish and sea turtles! In fact, there were ALWAYS sea turtles there. I think a couple of them live under a board under the dock, so they were always around.
THE VIEW! Just sitting on the deck or dock and looking out at the crystal-clear green waters or even the sunset was surreal.
THE STAFF. Dewitt and Cedrick were quite nice. Answered all our questions quickly.
THE KAYAKS were fully functional and worked great. We kayaked around one day just to explore and even found some large starfish!
Also, the master bedroom bed was very comfortable to sleep on, the A/C in the bedrooms worked great (not so much the living room one); No bugs inside; The stove, refrigerator, sink and shower work great and water pressure is good. Oh, they say they have "well" water, but it's actually the front deck is one big tank that they fill with water when it runs low. We tested the water for all sorts of things, including bacteria and it all came back negative, which is a good thing! (hardness was a little high, but that was it).
But, as much as we loved the place, Dewitt Cedrick & all, I've got to say maintenance isn't so great. And I mean the simple things. For the price, we would have expected a cleaner unit and cleaner windows! When 80% of what we are paying for is the view, I would have expected the windows to be spotless. They did have Windex and paper towels though so the next renter can thank me for cleaning all the front harbor facing windows. They were literally so dirty that it looked like I was looking through a fog bank out of them. The floors weren't that clean either and some of the blinds had to be manually rolled up each morning. The electrical meter box is also not latched shut so when the wind blows (which it did for several nights during our stay), it constantly bangs open and closed. One of the worst things is the septic tank or sewer smell that comes from the bathroom. Leave the door open and eventually the whole house smells. The smell might be coming from under the sink, we couldn't tell. :-(