This is a charming hotel in the perfect location, with an incredible rooftop area and very helpful service. I'll mention a few small downsides but then say why I think it is such a great place to stay. The biggest downside (which really didn't bother me, but might some people) is that, unless I misunderstood badly, you can't flush toilet paper down the toilet but have to put it in a bin instead. The bin is lined and has a lid, so it's really not bad, but takes some getting used to. A second downside, which I'm sure was my fault, is that I never figured out how to get the shower to be hot. I bet if I had asked at reception they would have told me how it works. Thirdly, and finally, my room was advertised as small and it was. But it was perfectly big enough for me, the bathroom was pretty big, and I paid a low price because the room was smaller. So, really not much of a downside at all.
The best things about the hotel are the location (right next to the old city, so easy to walk to the main things you want to see and convenient for taxis, restaurants, etc.), the friendly service, and the amazing rooftop, which allows you to see the whole city. At night the Citadel (aka Tower of David) puts on a light show with music, and you get a perfect view from this rooftop. I'm not sure how anyone else would ever see it, so it's as if there were a show just for guests at this hotel. It's magical. There is also a big pair of binoculars so you can get a closeup view of the Temple Mount.